Time & Work
Learning Objectives
- Understand the fundamental concepts of Time & Work
- Apply key formulas and techniques to solve problems
- Practice with exam-level questions to build speed and accuracy
Mastering Time, Work, and Efficiency for the exam
Welcome to this comprehensive lesson on Time & Work, a high-yield topic in the mathematics module. This section explores the mathematical relationship between the speed of workers (efficiency), the duration they work, and the total quantity of work completed. We will also extend these principles to Pipes & Cisterns problems and scenarios involving alternating work schedules. By mastering these concepts, you will be able to solve complex questions quickly during the exam.
Core Concepts: Efficiency, Time, and Work
The fundamental rule of this topic is that Work Done is directly proportional to Efficiency and inversely proportional to Time. Efficiency is defined as the amount of work a person or machine can complete in one unit of time. If Person A takes 10 days to finish a job, their daily efficiency is calculated as 1/10th of the total job. Conversely, if Person B takes 5 days, their efficiency is 1/5th. Notice that higher efficiency results in less time required to complete the same task. Combined Work occurs when two or more people work together; in this case, you simply add their individual daily efficiencies (e.g., 1/10 + 1/5) to find the total rate of completion per day. The total number of days required is found by dividing the total work (usually considered as 1 unit) by this combined daily rate.
Pipes & Cisterns: A Variation of Time & Work
Problems involving pipes filling or emptying a tank are mathematically identical to Time & Work problems, provided you understand the sign convention for rates. In these scenarios, Filling Pipes add water to the tank, representing positive work similar to a worker building something. Emptying Pipes remove water from the tank, representing negative work or a hindrance to the process. The net rate of change in the tank's volume is calculated by adding the filling rates and subtracting the emptying rates. For example, if Pipe A fills a tank in 10 hours and Pipe B empties it in 20 hours, the combined rate is (1/10) - (1/20). If both pipes are opened simultaneously, you must calculate this net difference to determine how long the tank will take to fill or empty.
Alternate Day Work
This advanced pattern occurs when two workers do not work together every day but instead take turns. For instance, A works on Monday and Wednesday, while B works on Tuesday and Thursday. To solve this, first calculate the Least Common Multiple (LCM) of the days taken by each worker to complete the job individually; let us assume this LCM is 60 units of work for simplicity. If A takes 15 days, their efficiency is 4 units/day. If B takes 20 days, their efficiency is 3 units/day. In an alternate schedule where they work on different days, you calculate the total work done in one full cycle (A's turn + B's turn). If this combined work per cycle exceeds the LCM, the job finishes within that cycle; if not, you continue adding cycles until the remaining work is less than or equal to the work capacity of the person whose turn it is next.
Solved Examples
a) 5 days
b) 6 days
c) 7 days
d) 8 days
Step-by-step reasoning:
1. Assume the total work is 1 unit.
2. A's efficiency = 1/10 per day.
3. B's efficiency = 1/15 per day.
4. Combined efficiency = (1/10) + (1/15).
5. To add fractions, find the LCM of 10 and 15, which is 30.
6. Convert to common denominator: (3/30) + (2/30) = 5/30.
7. Simplify the fraction: 5/30 reduces to 1/6.
8. This means together they complete 1/6th of the work in one day.
9. Therefore, total days required = 1 / (1/6) = 6 days.
a) 15 hours
b) 20 hours
c) 30 hours
d) 40 hours
Solution breakdown:
1. Treat filling as positive work and emptying as negative work.
2. Rate of Pipe A (filling) = +1/10 per hour.
3. Rate of Pipe B (emptying) = -1/20 per hour.
4. Net rate = (1/10) - (1/20).
5. Common denominator is 20: (2/20) - (1/20) = 1/20.
6. The net result is that 1/20th of the tank is filled every hour.
7. Total time to fill = 1 / (1/20) = 20 hours?
Common Traps
Students often fall into specific pitfalls that lead to incorrect answers.
- Mistaking Inverse Proportionality: Students sometimes think if A is twice as efficient, they take double the time. This is wrong; higher efficiency means LESS time taken.
- Ignoring Negative Signs in Pipes: When an outlet pipe is involved, forgetting to subtract its rate leads to adding two positive numbers, resulting in a time that is too short.
- Wrong LCM Calculation: In alternate work problems, using the wrong Least Common Multiple for the total work unit makes the arithmetic messy and prone to error. Always use the LCM of the individual days taken.
Memory Tricks
To remember these concepts quickly during the exam, use these analogies.
- The "Speed vs Time" Rule: Think of efficiency like speed in a car journey. If you drive faster (high efficiency), you reach your destination sooner (low time). Speed and Time are always inversely related.
- The "Bank Account" Analogy for Pipes: Imagine the tank is a bank account. Filling pipes are deposits (+), and emptying pipes are withdrawals (-). Your net balance grows only if deposits exceed withdrawals.
- The "Fraction Sum" Shortcut: When adding fractions like 1/10 + 1/15, remember that the numerator of the answer is usually small (like 1 or 2) and the denominator is the LCM. If you get a complex fraction, check your addition.
Work Equivalence and Man‑Day Calculations
Man‑days (person‑days) provide a universal unit for comparing work across groups of varying sizes and efficiencies. One man‑day is the work a standard‑efficiency worker completes in one day. Different efficiencies are converted to equivalent standard man‑days. If A is twice as efficient as standard, one day of A’s work equals two man‑days. Total project work is expressed as a fixed number of man‑days, W. With n workers of varying efficiencies, daily man‑day contribution is the sum of their efficiency factors. Required time = W ÷ (sum of daily efficiency factors). This avoids fractions and handles mid‑project entry/exit by adjusting the daily sum from the change day.
Scaling the Work Unit
Using the LCM of individual times as total work is a practical shortcut. If A finishes in 12 days and B in 18 days, LCM(12, 18) = 36. Treat the job as 36 units. A’s efficiency = 3 units/day; B’s = 2 units/day. Combined output = 5 units/day; time = 36 ÷ 5 = 7.2 days. The method extends to any number of workers and to pipes/cisterns (filling = positive, emptying = negative).
Handling Partial Contributions
For partial-day work, multiply daily efficiency by the fraction worked. A worker at 4 units/day working half a day contributes 2 units. Linear scaling assumes constant efficiency over the period. If efficiency changes mid‑project, split the timeline into constant‑efficiency phases, compute work per phase, and sum.
Variable Efficiency and Partial Work
Real work often involves non‑constant efficiency. Workers may speed up with experience or slow down from fatigue. Pipes may develop leaks, reducing fill rates. Divide the timeline into constant‑efficiency intervals. Work per interval = efficiency × interval length. Sum of interval work = total work. Known total work lets you solve for unknown interval lengths algebraically.
Workers Joining or Leaving Mid‑Project
Take a 120‑unit project. A starts alone at 5 units/day. After 4 days, B (3 units/day) joins. Three days later, A leaves. First 4 days: 5 × 4 = 20 units. Next 3 days: combined 8 units/day → 24 units. Remaining = 76 units; B alone at 3 units/day → 76 ÷ 3 ≈ 25.33 days. Total = 4 + 3 + 25.33 = 32.33 days. This piecewise method avoids the error of averaging efficiencies over the whole period.
Efficiency Change Due to External Factors
In pipe problems, a leak appearing at half‑full reduces the net fill rate. Treat as two stages: pre‑leak (net rate = sum of inlets) and post‑leak (net rate = sum of inlets − leak rate). Compute time to half‑full at first rate, then time for remaining half at reduced rate. Same logic applies when worker efficiency drops due to health or tool wear.
Step 1: Total work = LCM(20, 30) = 60 units.
Step 2: A’s efficiency = 60 ÷ 20 = 3 units/day. B’s efficiency = 60 ÷ 30 = 2 units/day.
Step 3: Work by A in first 5 days = 3 × 5 = 15 units.
Step 4: Combined efficiency = 3 + 2 = 5 units/day. Work in next 4 days = 5 × 4 = 20 units.
Step 5: Cumulative work = 15 + 20 = 35 units. Remaining = 60 − 35 = 25 units.
Step 6: B alone at 2 units/day → time = 25 ÷ 2 = 12.5 days.
Step 7: Total days = 5 + 4 + 12.5 = 21.5 days.
Multiple Inlet and Outlet Pipes with Time Gaps
Pipes/cisterns problems get harder when pipes aren't opened simultaneously. Net fill rate changes whenever a pipe opens or closes. Treat the process as sequential phases, each with a fixed set of active pipes. Per phase: net rate = sum of inlets − sum of outlets; volume = net rate × phase duration. Tank capacity = LCM of individual times, giving whole‑number rates per hour.
Sequential Opening and Closing
Example: A fills in 10 hr, B in 15 hr, C empties in 30 hr. A opens at t = 0. At 2 hr, B opens. At 5 hr, C opens. Capacity = LCM(10, 15, 30) = 30 units. Rates: A = 3, B = 2, C = −1 units/hr. Phase 1 (0–2 hr): A only → 6 units. Phase 2 (2–5 hr): A+B → 15 units. Cumulative = 21 units. Phase 3 (5 hr+): A+B+C → net 4 units/hr. Remaining 9 units → 9 ÷ 4 = 2.25 hr. Total = 7.25 hr.
Intermittent Operation
Some problems have pipes operating cyclically (on/off). Treat each cycle as a block: compute net work/cycle, find full cycles needed, then handle remainder with a partial cycle. This mirrors alternate‑day logic with continuous time.
Alternate Day Work with Breaks and Changing Efficiencies
Basic alternate‑day model: two workers alternate daily without breaks. Variants add rest days, efficiency changes after cycles, or a third worker. Core technique: define the smallest repeating work‑day pattern as a cycle, compute work/cycle, find how many full cycles fit total work. If remainder ≤ next worker’s daily capacity, job finishes on their turn; else an extra partial day is needed.
Rest Days in the Rotation
Example: A works Day 1, rests Day 2; B works Day 3, rests Day 4; repeat. Cycle = 4 days, 2 work days. Work/cycle = A’s efficiency + B’s efficiency. Total work = LCM of individual completion times. Full cycles = total work ÷ work/cycle; process remainder day by day.
Efficiency Upgrade After Fixed Cycles
A may become 50% more efficient after 3 cycles. Split timeline: first 3 cycles at original efficiency, rest at upgraded. Compute work in first 3 cycles, subtract from total, continue with new per‑cycle work. Avoids retroactively applying upgraded efficiency.
Combined Work with Wage Distribution and Share Calculation
Wages are typically split in proportion to work contributed. Worker’s share = (worker’s work units ÷ total work units) × total wages. With varying efficiencies/durations, contribution = efficiency × days worked. Contribution ratios determine wage split. Applies to pipes too: inlet contributions determine payout; outlets are a cost.
Wages with Idle Time
Idle time (e.g., waiting for materials) doesn't count toward share. Problems usually specify attendance‑ vs output‑based wages. Output‑based: idle time = zero contribution.
Multiple Contractors and Sub‑Contracting
Main contractors may hire simultaneous sub‑contractors. Main contractor often gets fixed % + share of remaining profit proportional to their direct work. Let total profit = P. Main contractor = fixed % + (own work ÷ total work) × remaining profit. Solve for unknowns given total profit or individual shares.
- Using a single average efficiency when efficiencies change at known points.
- Not converting pipe rates to a common unit (LCM) before adding/subtracting.
- Treating alternate‑day work as simple addition ignoring turn order.
- Ignoring rest days/breaks, overestimating work per cycle.
- Applying upgraded efficiency retroactively to earlier cycles.
- Dividing wages equally instead of by work contributed.
- Review these traps before the exam.