Module 3 · RBI Grade B Quantitative Aptitude

Profit, Loss & Discount

Updated 18 Nov 2026 · 4,392 words · 6 sections · illustrated
Updated 17 Nov 2026
CP/SP, markup, discount.
CP/SP · Markup & Discount
🎯 Take Mock Test
Cost Price (CP) &Selling Price (SP)Marked Price &DiscountSuccessiveDiscountsFalse Weights &MeasuresEqual SP ↔ CP of X= SP of YChains, Cycles &Data Sufficiencyprice reductionapply sequentiallyExam hook: “Find net discount when 3 successive discounts are given”vlymbooq
Concept Map of Profit, Loss & Discount Mechanics — Shows how core commercial‑arithmetic ideas connect and lead to exam‑type problems. · Open the full diagram →

Learning Objectives

  • Understand the fundamental concepts of Profit, Loss & Discount
  • Apply key formulas and techniques to solve problems
  • Practice with exam-level questions to build speed and accuracy

Foundations of Commercial Arithmetic: Cost Price and Selling Price

1.1 The Transaction Cycle and the Definition of Cost Price

Every commercial transaction begins with an acquisition, and the monetary value assigned to that acquisition forms the bedrock of all subsequent profit or loss calculations. The cost price represents the total outlay incurred by a trader to bring an article into a saleable condition, encompassing not only the invoice price paid to the supplier but also unavoidable overheads such as freight, octroi, import duties, and any expenditure on repair or refurbishment before the goods are offered for sale. It is critical to understand that cost price is not merely a static label on a ledger; it is a dynamic aggregate that determines the baseline from which profitability is measured. When a question states that a shopkeeper buys an article for a certain sum, the examinee must instinctively verify whether that sum represents the pure purchase price or the effective cost price after including incidentals, because an error in identifying the true cost price propagates through every subsequent percentage calculation.

1.2 Selling Price as the Realisation of Value

The selling price is the consideration received by the seller upon transferring ownership of the goods to the buyer, and it serves as the sole metric for determining whether the venture resulted in a gain or a loss. Unlike the cost price, which looks backward at expenditure, the selling price looks forward at revenue realisation. The relationship between these two figures is binary and absolute: if the selling price exceeds the cost price, the difference constitutes a profit; if the cost price exceeds the selling price, the difference constitutes a loss. There is no third state in elementary commercial arithmetic, though a break-even scenario where selling price equals cost price represents the mathematical boundary between the two. Students must internalise that profit and loss are always calculated as a percentage of the cost price unless the problem explicitly directs otherwise, a convention rooted in the principle that the investor measures return on the capital actually deployed.

1.3 The Algebra of Profit and Loss Percentages

The standard formulae — Profit Percentage equals Profit divided by Cost Price multiplied by one hundred, and Loss Percentage equals Loss divided by Cost Price multiplied by one hundred — are not arbitrary rules but direct expressions of the rate of return on investment. When a problem states that an article was sold at a profit of twenty percent, it implies that the selling price is one hundred and twenty percent of the cost price, allowing the student to construct the equation Selling Price equals Cost Price multiplied by one plus the profit percentage divided by one hundred. Conversely, a loss of twenty percent means the selling price is eighty percent of the cost price. This multiplicative relationship is the engine that drives almost every variation of the topic, from finding the cost price when the selling price and profit percentage are known, to solving complex chains of transactions where an article passes through multiple hands, each adding a layer of profit or loss. Mastery of this algebraic translation — moving fluently between the language of percentages and the language of fractions — is the single most determinative skill for speed and accuracy in the examination hall.

1.4 The Concept of Equal Percentage Profit and Loss on Identical Selling Prices

A frequently examined nuance arises when two articles are sold at the same selling price, one at a profit of x percent and the other at a loss of x percent. Intuition often suggests that the profit and loss cancel each other out, resulting in a break-even situation, but the mathematics dictates otherwise because the cost prices of the two articles are necessarily different. The article sold at a profit had a lower cost base, while the article sold at a loss had a higher cost base; therefore, the absolute rupee amount of the loss exceeds the absolute rupee amount of the profit. The net result is always a loss, and its percentage is given by the formula x squared divided by one hundred. This result is independent of the actual selling price and depends solely on the magnitude of the percentage x. Recognising this pattern allows a candidate to solve such problems in seconds without constructing simultaneous equations, turning a potential time sink into a guaranteed mark.

Marked Price, Discount, and the Mechanics of Price Reduction

2.1 The Role of Marked Price in Retail Strategy

The marked price, often labelled as the list price or the printed price, is the price tag attached to the article before any negotiation or promotional reduction takes place. It functions as a strategic anchor set by the retailer, typically above the cost price to provide a buffer for bargaining, seasonal sales, or volume discounts. The difference between the marked price and the cost price is known as the markup, and the markup percentage is calculated on the cost price, reflecting the trader's intended gross margin before any customer-facing concessions. Understanding the distinction between markup (calculated on cost price) and discount (calculated on marked price) is essential because the two percentages operate on different bases; a markup of fifty percent followed by a discount of fifty percent does not return the trader to the cost price but results in a loss, since the discount is applied to a larger base than the markup.

2.2 Discount Calculation and its Impact on Selling Price

Discount is a reduction offered on the marked price to incentivise a sale, and it is always expressed as a percentage of the marked price. The selling price is therefore derived by subtracting the discount amount from the marked price, or equivalently, by multiplying the marked price by the factor one minus the discount percentage divided by one hundred. This direct relationship means that if any two of the three variables — marked price, discount percentage, and selling price — are known, the third can be determined instantly. Examination questions often reverse this logic, providing the selling price and the discount percentage and asking for the marked price, which requires the candidate to divide the selling price by the factor one minus the discount percentage divided by one hundred. Fluency in this inversion is a hallmark of a well-prepared student.

2.3 Interlinking Cost Price, Marked Price, and Selling Price

The complete commercial chain connects cost price to marked price through markup, and marked price to selling price through discount. A typical problem might state that a shopkeeper marks his goods forty percent above the cost price and allows a discount of ten percent; the task is to find the effective profit percentage. Here, the candidate must recognise that the selling price equals the cost price multiplied by one plus the markup percentage divided by one hundred, further multiplied by one minus the discount percentage divided by one hundred. The effective profit percentage is then the deviation of this composite multiplier from unity, expressed as a percentage. This chaining of multipliers is the most robust method for solving such problems because it avoids the pitfall of calculating intermediate rupee values that may not be integers, keeping the arithmetic clean and the logic transparent.

2.4 The Scenario of Successive Markups or Discounts on the Same Base

Occasionally, a problem presents a situation where a price is increased by a certain percentage and then decreased by another percentage, or vice versa, with both percentages applied to the same original base rather than successively. This is distinct from successive percentage changes, where the second change applies to the result of the first. When changes apply to the same base, the net effect is the algebraic sum of the individual percentages; a markup of twenty percent followed by a discount of fifteen percent on the original marked price yields a net increase of five percent on that base. However, the standard retail model assumes successive application — the discount applies to the already marked-up price — and candidates must read the wording with precision to distinguish between these two fundamentally different mathematical structures.

Illustrative Problem: Markup, Discount, and Effective Profit
A trader marks his goods 50% above the cost price. He sells half the stock at the marked price, one quarter at a discount of 20% on the marked price, and the rest at a discount of 40% on the marked price. What is his overall profit percentage?
Solution: Let the total cost price of the stock be Rs. 100 units (or any convenient base). Since the markup is 50%, the total marked price of the stock is Rs. 150 units. The stock is divided into three parts: half (50% of cost base), one quarter (25% of cost base), and the remaining quarter (25% of cost base). However, it is simpler to assume the cost price of each unit is Re. 1 and total units are 4. Total CP = Rs. 4. Marked Price per unit = Rs. 1.50. Total MP = Rs. 6. Sale 1: Half the stock (2 units) at MP. Revenue = 2 × 1.50 = Rs. 3. Sale 2: One quarter (1 unit) at 20% discount. SP = 1.50 × 0.80 = Rs. 1.20. Revenue = Rs. 1.20. Sale 3: Remaining quarter (1 unit) at 40% discount. SP = 1.50 × 0.60 = Rs. 0.90. Revenue = Rs. 0.90. Total Selling Price = 3 + 1.20 + 0.90 = Rs. 5.10. Total Cost Price = Rs. 4.00. Profit = Rs. 1.10. Profit Percentage = (1.10 / 4.00) × 100 = 27.5%.
Examination Insight
In questions involving partial sales at different discount rates, always assume a convenient total quantity (like 4, 10, or 100 units) or a convenient total cost price (like Rs. 100) rather than an algebraic variable. This converts abstract percentages into concrete arithmetic, drastically reducing the chance of algebraic slips under time pressure.

Successive Discounts and the Equivalent Single Discount

3.1 The Mechanism of Successive Percentage Reductions

When a trader offers two or more discounts in sequence — for example, a festival discount of twenty percent followed by a loyalty discount of ten percent — the second discount is applied not to the original marked price but to the reduced price that results from the first discount. This compounding effect means that the total reduction is not the arithmetic sum of the two percentages but a slightly smaller figure, because the base for the second discount has already been shrunk by the first. The formula for the equivalent single discount when two discounts of x percent and y percent are applied successively is x plus y minus the product of x and y divided by one hundred. This formula is derived directly from the multiplicative logic: the final selling price equals the marked price multiplied by (one minus x/100) multiplied by (one minus y/100), and expanding this product yields the equivalent single discount factor.

3.2 Extending the Logic to Three or More Successive Discounts

The principle extends naturally to three or more successive discounts. If discounts of x percent, y percent, and z percent are offered in succession, the equivalent single discount can be found by first combining x and y into an intermediate equivalent discount d1 using the two-discount formula, and then combining d1 with z using the same formula again. Alternatively, the candidate can multiply the three retention factors (100 minus x)/100, (100 minus y)/100, and (100 minus z)/100, subtract the product from one, and multiply by one hundred. The multiplicative approach is generally faster and less error-prone for three or more discounts because it avoids the iterative application of the subtraction formula and keeps the arithmetic in the domain of fractions.

3.3 Comparing Successive Discounts with a Single Discount of Equal Sum

A classic comparative question asks whether a single discount of thirty percent is better for the buyer than two successive discounts of twenty percent and ten percent. Since the equivalent single discount for twenty percent and ten percent is twenty-eight percent (20 + 10 - 2), the single discount of thirty percent is more favourable to the buyer, yielding a lower selling price. This comparison tests the candidate's understanding that successive discounts are always less beneficial to the buyer — and more beneficial to the seller — than a single discount equal to their sum. The difference, which is the product term divided by one hundred, represents the "discount on the discount" that the seller retains by structuring the concession in stages.

3.4 Successive Increases and the Symmetry of the Formula

The same mathematical structure governs successive percentage increases, such as a price hike of ten percent followed by a further hike of twenty percent. The equivalent single increase is given by x plus y plus the product of x and y divided by one hundred, where the sign of the product term is positive because both changes amplify the base. If a problem mixes an increase and a decrease — for instance, a price is increased by twenty percent and then decreased by twenty percent — the equivalent single change is a decrease of four percent (20 - 20 - 400/100 = -4). This demonstrates that an equal percentage increase followed by an equal percentage decrease never restores the original value; it always results in a net decrease equal to the square of the percentage divided by one hundred, a direct analogue of the profit-loss symmetry discussed earlier.

Comparison of Single Discount vs. Successive Discounts for Buyer and Seller
Scenario Marked Price (Rs.) Discount Structure Selling Price (Rs.) Beneficiary
Single Discount 1000 30% 700 Buyer (Lower Price)
Successive Discounts 1000 20% then 10% 720 Seller (Higher Revenue)
Difference — — Rs. 20 Seller retains "discount on discount"
Cost Price & SPMarked Price &DiscountSuccessiveDiscountsFalse WeightsEqual SP / CP=SPChains & Cyclessets MPappliesmisusespecial caseextendsKey Formula: Discount% = (MP‑SP)/MP ×100Exam Hook: CP = SP × 100/(100+Profit%)vlymbooq
Profit Loss Discount Concept Flow Diagram for Exams — Shows the logical chain from cost price through discounts to advanced problem types. · Open the full diagram →

Dishonest Dealings: False Weights and Measures

4.1 The Fundamental Deception of False Weight

A distinct category of problems deals with a trader who claims to sell at cost price or at a stated profit percentage but uses a weighing scale that shows a higher quantity than the actual quantity delivered. This practice allows the trader to charge for goods not actually given, creating a hidden profit that is purely a function of the discrepancy between the true weight and the false weight. The standard formula for the profit percentage in such cases is the difference between the true weight and the false weight divided by the false weight, multiplied by one hundred. The denominator is the false weight because that represents the actual quantity the trader parts with — his effective cost base — while the numerator represents the quantity he charges for but does not deliver, which is his illicit gain.

4.2 Combining False Weight with Stated Profit or Loss

Problems often compound the deception by stating that the shopkeeper sells at a nominal profit of ten percent while using a weight of nine hundred grams for a kilogram. In this scenario, the overall profit percentage is not a simple sum. The correct approach is to treat the transaction as two successive multiplications on the cost price: first, the stated profit multiplier (1.10), and second, the weight cheating multiplier (True Weight / False Weight = 1000/900 = 10/9). The overall multiplier is the product of these two factors, and the overall profit percentage is the deviation of this product from one, expressed as a percentage. This multiplicative chaining ensures that the profit on the cheating is calculated on the already inflated selling price, capturing the compounding effect that a simple additive approach would miss.

4.3 The Case of the Dishonest Buyer

The mirror image of the dishonest seller is the dishonest buyer who uses a false weight while purchasing, obtaining more quantity than he pays for. If a buyer uses a scale that shows nine hundred grams when the true weight is one kilogram, he receives one thousand grams for the price of nine hundred. His gain percentage is calculated using the same logic: the extra quantity obtained (100 grams) divided by the quantity paid for (900 grams), multiplied by one hundred, yielding 11.11 percent. When a dishonest buyer meets a dishonest seller in a single transaction chain, the overall effect is the product of their individual gain multipliers, a scenario that occasionally appears in advanced data interpretation sets or caselets.

4.4 Liquid Adulteration as a Volume Analogue

The principle of false weight extends seamlessly to liquid adulteration, where a trader mixes water (assumed to have zero cost) with milk or another liquid and sells the mixture at the cost price of the pure liquid. If one litre of milk is mixed with two hundred millilitres of water and the resulting 1.2 litres is sold at the cost price of one litre of pure milk, the trader effectively sells 1.2 litres for the price of 1 litre. The profit percentage is the volume of water added divided by the volume of pure milk, multiplied by one hundred (200/1000 × 100 = 20%). This is mathematically identical to the false weight problem, with volume replacing weight, and the same multiplicative logic applies if the mixture is sold at a stated profit or discount.

Comparison of Honest vs. Dishonest Trading Scenarios
Parameter Honest Trader (Standard) Dishonest Trader (False Weight) Dishonest Trader (Adulteration)
Claimed Basis Sells 1 kg for CP of 1 kg Sells "1 kg" (actually 900g) for CP of 1 kg Sells 1.2 L mixture for CP of 1 L pure
Actual Quantity Given 1000 g 900 g 1000 g milk + 200 ml water
Cost Incurred CP of 1000 g CP of 900 g CP of 1000 g milk
Revenue Received CP of 1000 g CP of 1000 g CP of 1200 ml mixture
Profit % Formula (SP - CP)/CP × 100 (True Wt - False Wt)/False Wt × 100 (Adulterant Volume / Pure Volume) × 100

Special Transaction Structures: Equal SP, CP of X equals SP of Y, and Partnership

5.1 The "Cost Price of X Articles Equals Selling Price of Y Articles" Model

A perennially favourite examination pattern states that the cost price of x articles is equal to the selling price of y articles, asking the candidate to find the profit or loss percentage. This relationship implies that the revenue from selling y articles exactly covers the cost of x articles. If x is greater than y, the cost base is larger than the revenue base for the same number of transactions, indicating a loss; if y is greater than x, it indicates a profit. The profit percentage is given by the formula (y minus x) divided by x multiplied by one hundred when y > x, and the loss percentage is (x minus y) divided by x multiplied by one hundred when x > y. This formula is derived by equating the total cost price of x articles to the total selling price of y articles, assuming a unit cost price, and solving for the percentage deviation. Recognising this pattern allows for an immediate answer without any intermediate calculation of per-unit prices.

5.2 Transactions Involving Free Articles or "Buy X Get Y Free" Offers

Modern retail promotions such as "Buy two get one free" or "Buy three get two free" are mathematically equivalent to the CP-SP equality model. In a "Buy 2 get 1 free" offer, the customer pays for two articles and receives three. The seller's cost is for three articles, but his revenue is from two. This maps directly to the formula with x = 3 (cost articles) and y = 2 (paid articles), resulting in a loss percentage of (3-2)/3 × 100 = 33.33% if the marked price equals the cost price. However, if the marked price includes a markup, the effective profit or loss must be calculated by comparing the total revenue (marked price × paid quantity) with the total cost (cost price × total quantity delivered). The multiplicative framework — Revenue Multiplier = (Paid Qty / Total Qty) × (Marked Price / Cost Price) — handles all such variations uniformly.

5.3 Partnership and Profit Sharing Ratios

While partnership is often taught as a separate chapter, its arithmetic core is identical to profit and loss: the division of a net gain (or loss) among partners in proportion to their capital contributions weighted by the time for which the capital was employed. The profit sharing ratio is the ratio of the products of capital and time for each partner. If a partner joins or leaves mid-year, or if additional capital is introduced or withdrawn, the time-weighting must be calculated in months or days with precision. A common trap is to average the capitals or to ignore the time factor entirely, leading to an incorrect ratio. The connection to the current topic is explicit when a question asks for the profit percentage of the firm overall, which is calculated on the total capital employed over the period, and then the individual shares are derived from the agreed ratio.

5.4 The Concept of Marked Price with Sales Tax or GST

Contemporary problems sometimes introduce a statutory tax such as Goods and Services Tax (GST) levied on the selling price. The marked price is the pre-tax price tag; the selling price inclusive of tax is the marked price plus the tax amount. If a problem states that a customer pays a certain amount inclusive of tax, and the trader offers a discount on the marked price, the candidate must first strip the tax from the amount paid to find the actual selling price (revenue to the trader), and then work backwards to the marked price or cost price. The tax is a pass-through liability for the trader and does not form part of his revenue or cost base for profit calculation; confusing the tax-inclusive price with the selling price is a frequent and costly error.

Advanced Problem Solving: Chains, Cycles, and Data Sufficiency

6.1 Multi-Stage Transaction Chains

Examination questions frequently construct a chain where a manufacturer sells to a wholesaler at a profit, the wholesaler sells to a retailer at a profit, and the retailer sells to a consumer at a profit or after a discount. The final selling price to the consumer is given, and the candidate is asked to find the manufacturer's cost price. The most efficient method is to work backwards from the consumer price, dividing by the retailer's multiplier (1 + profit%/100 or 1 - discount%/100), then by the wholesaler's multiplier, and finally by the manufacturer's multiplier. This reverse engineering avoids the accumulation of rounding errors that can occur when working forward with an assumed variable, and it naturally handles the different bases (each stage calculates profit on its own cost price) without confusion.

6.2 Cyclic Transactions and the Illusion of Profit

A cyclic transaction occurs when A sells to B, B sells to C, and C sells back to A, each at a stated profit percentage. If the cycle closes at the same price at which it started, the product of all the multipliers must equal one. If the product is greater than one, the final price is higher than the initial price, implying that the last buyer (A) pays more than his original cost, which is impossible in a closed loop unless external money enters. Such problems test the candidate's ability to set up the equation: Initial Price × (1 + p1/100) × (1 + p2/100) × (1 + p3/100) = Final Price, and solve for the unknown percentage or the initial price. The key insight is that every participant in the chain calculates profit on their own cost price, so the multipliers chain multiplicatively, not additively.

6.3 Data Sufficiency in Profit and Loss Contexts

In the Data Sufficiency format, the candidate must determine whether the given statements provide enough information to answer the question, without necessarily solving it. For profit and loss, a common question asks for the profit percentage. Statement I might give the ratio of cost price to selling price (sufficient, as profit% = (SP/CP - 1) × 100). Statement II might give the absolute profit in rupees (insufficient alone, as the cost price is unknown). Statement III might give the marked price and discount percentage (sufficient, as SP can be found, but CP is still needed unless markup info is also given). The ability to instantly recognise which combinations of variables (CP, SP, MP, Profit%, Loss%, Discount%, Markup%) are sufficient to determine the target variable is a high-yield skill that separates high scorers from average performers.

6.4 Approximation and Fraction-Percentage Equivalence for Speed

Finally, computational speed in this topic is heavily dependent on the candidate's fluency with common fraction-percentage equivalents. Knowing that 1/8 = 12.5%, 1/6 = 16.66%, 1/7 ≈ 14.28%, 1/9 = 11.11%, and 1/11 = 9.09% allows the conversion of awkward percentages like 37.5% (3/8) or 62.5% (5/8) into simple fractions, turning multiplications into cancellations. For instance, a profit of 37.5% means SP = CP × (1 + 3/8) = CP × 11/8. If the selling price is given as Rs. 440, the cost price is 440 × 8/11 = 320, solved mentally in seconds. Building and maintaining a mental table of these equivalences up to at least 1/20 is not a shortcut but a fundamental requirement for attempting the quantitative section within the prescribed time limit.

Practice Questions

← Percentage Time & Work →