Three Pillars: Rights, Principles, Duties Compared

GS Paper 2Polity · hand-drawn SVG · redraw from memory

Compares the three constitutional pillars on justiciability, obligation type, focus, and judicial treatment, plus their interplay.

Fundamental Rights(Part III, Arts12–35)DirectivePrinciples (PartIV, Arts 36–51)Fundamental Duties(Part IVA, Art 51A)Justiciable Art 32/ 226 Negativeduties on State Individual-centric Strict scrutinyNon-justiciable Art37 declarationPositive duties on State State-centric Policy guidelinesMoral obligationsAdded 42nd Amend1976 Citizen-centric Enforceable by law 11 duties listedScope: Arts 14–32Equality, Freedom,Life, Religion, RemediesScope: Arts 38–51Social, Economic,Gandhian, Liberal, InternationalScope: Art 51AConstitution,Ideals, Nation, Harmony, Environment, etc.ChampakamDorairajan (1951)FR prevail over DPSP Golaknath (1967) FR immutableKesavananda (1973)Basic StructureMinerva Mills (1980) Harmonious construction FR & DPSP complementaryJaved (2003) Dutiesguide FRinterpretation Ranganath Mishra (2003) Duties enforceable by law Art 51A aids Art 21Fundamental Rights vs DPSP vs Fundamental DutiesInterplay, Tension & Harmonious ConstructionExam hook: Art 37 makes DPSP non-justiciable but fundamental in governance; Art 51A added by 42nd, 11th duty by 86th Amendment.vlymbooq

Part of the UPSC figure library — label-first sketches a candidate can reproduce in the exam hall. All 301 diagrams are inline SVG: no image can 404.